| 2026-2027 | |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Golf | Trey Speir |
| Boys Golf | Oscar Ford |
| 2025-2026 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Golf | Aspen Murphy |
| Girls Golf | Sarah Farmer |
| Girls Basketball | Natalie Bohannon |
| Cheer | Landri Supinski |
| Cheer | Izzy Pietschmann |
| Second Team | |
| Baseball | Nate Bovasso |
| Girls Soccer | Sylvia Alcorn |
| Girls Soccer | Lyla Scullion |
| Girls Golf | Kate Wilson |
| Girls Basketball | Tenley Fuller |
| Boys Golf | Trey Speir |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Baseball | Cuatro Wilkins |
| Baseball | Trey Speir |
| Baseball | Tanner McCoy |
| Girls Soccer | Kali Hobbs |
| Track & Field | Kamryn Peters |
| Track & Field | Maleah Thomson |
| Girls Basketball | Riah Moore |
| Girls Basketball | Teagan Fuller |
| Boys Basketball | Jayden Cain |
| Football | Quinn Barkema |
| Volleyball | Natalie Bohannon |
| Volleyball | Addison Ruter |
| Volleyball | Amina Weber |
| Cross Country | Luke Price |
| Cross Country | Reagan Oertli |
| Cross Country | Teagan Fuller |
| Cross Country | Maleah Thomson |
| Cross Country | Natalie Bohannon |
| Cross Country | Kamryn Peters |
| 2024-2025 | |
| First Team | |
| Baseball | James Lord |
| Baseball | Mason Reilly |
| Girls Soccer | Lyla Scullion |
| Girls Golf | Aspen Murphy |
| Girls Golf | Sarah Farmer |
| Girls Basketball | Kamiree Fuller |
| Cheer | Gracie Cassida |
| Cheer | Faith Budreau |
| Boys Soccer | Brady Kindig |
| Cross Country | Ian Reynolds |
| Second Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Kamiree Fuller |
| Track & Field | Brynn Goldfain |
| Track & Field | Paisley Lyons |
| Track & Field | Sam Baumgartel |
| Girls Basketball | Noelani Book |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Soccer | Lotte Nydam |
| Track & Field | Sam Baumgartel |
| Boys Basketball | Ryan Wind |
| Girls Basketball | Natalie Bohannon |
| Football | Trenton Steeves |
| Football | Carsyn Romero |
| Football | Diego Pellegrini |
| Volleyball | Ava Vande Griend |
| Boys Soccer | Landon Duncan |
| Boys Soccer | Elias Romero |
| Boys Soccer | Jess Nydam |
| Boys Soccer | Walker Politte |
| Cross Country | Natalie Bohannon |
| Cross Country | Kamiree Fuller |
| Cross Country | Teagan Fuller |
| 2023-2024 | |
| First Team | |
| Baseball | Asher Hawes |
| Baseball | Brayden Epperhart |
| Baseball | Mason Reilly |
| Cheer | Ella Herring |
| Cheer | Abigail Snow |
| Boys Soccer | Landon Duncan |
| Second Team | |
| Baseball | Caleb Stork |
| Girls Soccer | Lyla Scullion |
| Girls Soccer | Lotte Nydam |
| Track & Field | Ian Reynolds |
| Boys Basketball | Jackson Schroder |
| Football | Luke Booysen |
| Boys Soccer | Owen Kleager |
| Boys Soccer | Jess Nydam |
| Boys Soccer | Elias Romero |
| Cross Country | Teagan Fuller |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Baseball | James Lord |
| Baseball | Patrick Elson |
| Girls Soccer | Kamiree Fuller |
| Girls Soccer | Makenna Duntsch |
| Track & Field | Brynn Goldfain |
| Girls Basketball | Kamiree Fuller |
| Football | Brodie Wolff |
| Boys Soccer | Walker Politte |
| Cross Country | Ian Reynolds |
| 2022-2023 | |
| 1st Team | |
| Baseball | Asher Hawes |
| Baseball | Brayden Epperhart |
| Girls Soccer | Nerea Genc |
| Girls Soccer | Sydney Fitzgerald |
| Girls Golf | Quinn Wilson |
| Boys Soccer | Luke Dillon |
| Cheer | Payton Ruter |
| Second Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Courtney Johnson |
| Girls Golf | Riley Chalmers |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Soccer | Makenna Duntsch |
| Boys Basketball | Derrin Quinn |
| Girls Basketball | Natalie Beattie |
| Girls Basketball | Kamiree Fuller |
| Football | Luke Dorsey |
| Volleyball | Ashley Allen |
| Cross Country | Teagan Fuller |
| 2021-2022 | |
| 1st Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Sophie Bull |
| Girls Soccer | Nerea Genc |
| Boys Basketball | Ben Buhler |
| Cross Country | Sophie Bull |
| Cheer | Logan Fish |
| 2nd Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Sydney Fitzgerald |
| Girls Soccer | Taylor McNally |
| Boys Soccer | Luke Dillon |
| Boys Soccer | Derrin Quinn |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Basketball | Sophie Bull |
| Baseball | Asher Hawes |
| Baseball | Mason Reilly |
| Boys Basketball | Xander Neu |
| Volleyball | Grace Roth |
| Volleyball | Emily Sullivan |
| 2020-2021 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Nerea Genc |
| Girls Soccer | Sophie Bull |
| Cross Country | Sophie Bull |
| Boys Soccer | Caleb Riggs |
| Volleyball | Jacki Bogner |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Soccer | Mark Detrick |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Basketball | Sophie Bull |
| Baseball | Henry VanDenBerg |
| Boys Basketball | Ben Buhler |
| Boys Basketball | Henry VanDenBerg |
| Volleyball | Emily Sullivan |
| 2019-2020 | |
| First Team | |
| Volleyball | Jacki Bogner |
| Volleyball | Anna Kaemingk |
| Boys Soccer | Ryan Beattie |
| Boys Soccer | Caleb Riggs |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Basketball | Kara Amidon |
| Boys Basketball | Ben Buhler |
| Boys Soccer | Brayden Becker |
| Volleyball | Emily Sullivan |
| 2018-2019 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Eden Reece |
| Girls Soccer | Kaya Schaap |
| Girls Soccer | Kara Amidon |
| Boys Soccer | Brett Carlson |
| Volleyball | Anna Kaemingk |
| Second Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Holland Reece |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Basketball | Kara Amidon |
| Boys Soccer | Ryan Beattie |
| Boys Soccer | Brayden Becker |
| Boys Soccer | Zach Johnson |
| Volleyball | Jenna Peters |
| 2017-2018 | |
| First Team | |
| Track & Field | Mikaela Capalby |
| Track & Field | Ineka Cordova |
| Track & Field | Zoe Fierer |
| Track & Field | Monika Williams |
| Girls Soccer | Kara Amidon |
| Girls Soccer | Miranda Kortenhoeven |
| Girls Soccer | McKenna Mueller |
| Second Team | |
| Volleyball | Hally Herder |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Soccer | Sydney Beijer |
| Girls Soccer | Kaya Schapp |
| Girls Basketball | Miranda Kortenhoeven |
| Boys Basketball | Eu Asefaw |
| Boys Soccer | Jeff Amidon |
| 2016-2017 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Miranda Kortenhoeven |
| Girls Soccer | Kara Amidon |
| Girls Soccer | McKenna Mueller |
| Girls Soccer | Grace Phillips |
| Volleyball | Brittany Anton |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Soccer | Hally Herder |
| Baseball | Pete Lanting |
| Girls Basketball | Miranda Kortenhoeven |
| Volleyball | Hally Herder |
| 2015-2016 | |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Baseball | Pete Lanting |
| Girls Soccer | Audrey Scadden |
| 2014-2015 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Nicole Landhuis |
| Girls Soccer | Miranda Kortenhoeven |
| Boys Soccer | Jack McCool |
| Boys Soccer | Aric Aman |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Soccer | Levi Viss |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Baseball | Simon Becker |
| 2013-104 | |
| First Team | |
| Baseball | Tate Kastens |
| Baseball | Josh Van |
| Second Team | |
| Volleyball | Braya Hunt |
| 2012-2013 | |
| First Team | |
| Baseball | Tate Kastens |
| Baseball | Jacob Monsma |
| Baseball | Alex Terpstra |
| Boys Basketball | Alex Terpstra |
| Cross Country | Matt Smith |
| Cross Country | Miranda Middleton |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Basketball | Tate Kastens |
| Girls Basketball | Jerika Worth |
| Cross Country | Elijah Monroe |
| Cross Country | Baylee VerSteeg |
| Cross Country | Celeste Miller |
| 2011-2012 | |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Baseball | Chandler Van Dyke |
| Baseball | Jared Van Dyke |
| Girls Basketball | Jerika Worth |
| 2010-2011 | |
| First Team | |
| Baseball | Chris Van Dyke |
| Baseball | Daniel Miller |
| Boys Soccer | Jesse Ham |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Soccer | Jesse Montavon |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Basketball | Jerika Worth |
| 2009-2010 | |
| First Team | |
| Track & Field | Ryan Poland |
| Boys Soccer | Marcus Landhuis |
| Boys Soccer | Brent Ham |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Soccer | Colin Lanser |
| Boys Soccer | Jesse Montavon |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Track & Field | Ryan Poland |
| Baseball | Chris Van Dyke |
| Baseball | Daniel Miller |
| Boys Soccer | Jesse Ham |
| 2008-2009 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Lisa Singleton |
| Second Team | |
| Cross Country | Ryan Poland |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Soccer | Alexis Peterson |
| 2007-2008 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Basketball | John Lenderink |
| Boys Basketball | Beau Baker |
| Girls Basketball | Lindsay Landhuis |
| Boys Soccer | Ben Borger |
| Boys Soccer | Jack Reinsma |
| Boys Soccer | Keaton DeNooy |
| Boys Soccer | Brent Ham |
| Second Team | |
| Girls Basketball | Lucy Bell |
| Girls Basketball | Leanne Draayer |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Basketball | Zane Dacus |
| Girls Soccer | Alexis Peterson |
| Girls Soccer | Lisa Singleton |
| 2006-2007 | |
| First Team | |
| Football | Matt Newton |
| Football | Chad Colby |
| Football | Jordan Ham |
| Boys Soccer | Jeff Lanser |
| Boys Soccer | Michael McHugh |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Soccer | Joe Bailey |
| Boys Soccer | Charlie Dyrsten |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Soccer | Graham Ellsworth |
| Boys Soccer | Zach Pranger |
| 2005-2006 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Brent Schuster |
| Cross Country | Lisa Baity |
| Boys Soccer | Rustin Buteyn |
| Boys Soccer | Chris Gunnink |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Tristan Matthies |
| Honorable Mention | |
| 2004-2005 | |
| First Team | |
| Baseball | Kirk Nieuwenhuis |
| Football | Kirk Nieuwenhuis |
| Boys Soccer | Charlie Buteyn |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Jacob Vriesman |
| Boys Soccer | Ryan McGeady |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Soccer | Jim Reinsma |
| 2003-2004 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Soccer | David Dobias |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Soccer | Sam Duran |
| 2002-2003 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Daniel Lowery |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Ben Kurtz |
| Boys Basketball | Luke DeNooy |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Basketball | Travis Bowles |
| 2001-2002 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Emily Vogelzang |
| Cross Country | Bret Schoolmeester |
| Track & Field | Bret Schoolmeester |
| 2000-2001 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Emily Vogelzang |
| Cross Country | Bret Schoolmeester |
| Track & Field | Bret Schoolmeester |
| 1999-2000 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Emily Vogelzang |
| Baseball | Joe Jenkins |
| Track & Field | Bret Schoolmeester |
| Track & Field | Ben Buys |
| Boys Basketball | Ben Buys |
| Football | Ben Buys |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Track & Field | Jared Sparr |
| Girls Soccer | Kristine Gray |
| Girls Soccer | Missy Van Sickle |
| 1998-1999 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Emily Vogelzang |
| Girls Soccer | Tami Veenstra |
| Boys Basketball | Brian Van Eps |
| Cross Country | Jason Baker |
| Football | Ben Buys |
| 1997-1998 | |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Brian Van Eps |
| 1995-1996 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Jackie Bucher |
| Girls Soccer | Melanie Buys |
| Girls Soccer | Lindsay Grant |
| Girls Basketball | Jackie Bucher |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Basketball | Chris Van Heukelem |
| 1994-1995 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Jackie Bucher |
| Girls Soccer | Cara Jansen |
| Girls Soccer | Melanie Buys |
| Girls Basketball | Cara Jansen |
| Girls Basketball | Jackie Bucher |
| Second Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Lindsay Grant |
| Boys Soccer | Chris Van Heukelem |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Basketball | Bradd Bieshaar |
| Boys Basketball | Travis Lewis |
| Boys Soccer | Travis Lewis |
| 1993-1994 | |
| First Team | |
| Baseball | Matt Schreiber |
| Baseball | Ian Van Kooten |
| Girls Soccer | Rachel Verhoef |
| Girls Soccer | Keri Kitto |
| Girls Soccer | Cara Jansen |
| Boys Basketball | Brian Boonstra |
| Second Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Jackie Tamminga |
| Girls Basketball | Alison Price |
| Girls Basketball | Jackie Bucher |
| 1992-1993 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Keri Kitto |
| Girls Soccer | Amy Van Heukelem |
| Girls Soccer | Krista DeJong |
| Boys Basketball | Eric Boonstra |
| Second Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Cara Jansen |
| Girls Soccer | Rachel Verhof |
| Girls Soccer | Amy Horgan |
| Girls Basketball | Amy Van Heukelem |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Basketball | Leigh Boonstra |
| Girls Basketball | Jackie Bucher |
| 1991-1992 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Bobby Tamminga |
| Girls Basketball | Nicki Boonstra |
| Boys Soccer | Bobby Tamminga |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Soccer | Ben Dykstra |
| Boys Soccer | Greg Veenstra |
| 1990-1991 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Soccer | Bobby Tamminga |
| Boys Soccer | Roger Kamstra |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Soccer | Kris Dykman |
| 1989-1990 | |
| First Team | |
| Volleyball | Becky Van Heukelem |
| Second Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Scott Bliek |
| Boys Soccer | Dane Howard |
| 1987-1988 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Jen Tubergen |
| Boys Basketball | Scott Bliek |
| Girls Basketball | Jen Tubergen |
| Volleyball | Jen Tubergen |
| Second Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Missy Van Heukelem |
| 1986-1987 | |
| First Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Michelle Swierenga |
| Girls Soccer | Missy Van Heukelem |
| Girls Soccer | Jen Tubergen |
| Girls Basketball | Jen Tubergen |
| 1985-1986 | |
| First Team | |
| Football | Dan Spinder |
| Football | Carl Vellenga |
| Second Team | |
| Girls Soccer | Missy Van Heukelem |
| 1982-1983 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Craig Kispert |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Basketball | Greg LeFebre |
| 1980-1981 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Jim DeGroot |
| 1978-1979 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Craig Matthies |
| 1977-1978 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Eric Forseth |
| Boys Basketball | Craig Matthies |
| 1969-1970 | |
| First Team | |
| Boys Basketball | Ron Bosch |